The Behavior of Stibnite in an Oxidizing Roast. Discussion

Discussion of the paper of H. O. HOFMAN and JOHN BLATCHFORD, presented at the New York meeting, February, 1916, and printed in Bulletin No. 109, January, 1915, pp. 91 to 97. ROBERT H. RICHARDS, Boston, Mass.-I should like to ask Professor Hofman whether he is able to roast his stibnite without any comparatively large amount of loss of antimony? H. O. HOFMAN, Boston, Mass.-Yes. The last statement I made was that the loss of antimony, during those tests, increased with the temperature, and that up to 372° C. there was no loss whatever in antimony, also that it increased to 4:2I per cent. with 545° C., the highest temperature that we obtained in our small furnace. ROBERT H. RICHARDS.-I should like to ask a second question, and that is, is it not true that stibnite can be roasted more completely than any other sulphide?